Young Living Essential Oils VS Simply Earth Essential Oils – Comparing Essential Oils
Young Living Essential Oils VS Simply Earth Essential Oils – Comparing Essential Oils
Welcome back! Today, I’m diving into a comparison of two of my favorite essential oil brands: Simply Earth and Young Living. Spoiler alert—I love both! This isn’t a competition to crown one as superior, but rather a breakdown of the pros and cons of each brand, and a discussion on how they differ. Here is Young Living Essential Oils VS Simply Earth Essential Oils – Comparing Essential Oils.
Why Compare Simply Earth and Young Living?
With the vast market of essential oils out there, it can be overwhelming to decide which brand to trust. I’ve taken the time to explore many of these brands, and Simply Earth and Young Living stand out for a few reasons. While I’ve been a loyal Young Living customer for over two years, I’ve recently started exploring Simply Earth’s offerings. Here’s what I’ve discovered about both.
Simply Earth: Affordable and Educational
Simply Earth offers a unique approach to essential oils with their monthly subscription box. For just $39 a month, you receive four essential oils, recipe cards, and most of the ingredients needed to create DIY, non-toxic products. It’s a budget-friendly way to gradually transform your home into a safer, toxin-free environment. Whether you’re looking to swap out toxic cleaners, laundry products, or candles for natural alternatives, Simply Earth makes it easy.
What sets Simply Earth apart is their transparency and education. From the detailed product labels to the informative website, they’re committed to educating their customers. On each product page, they share vital details like the botanical name, origin, extraction method, and safety information (e.g., whether the oil is safe for kids, pregnant women, or pets). This level of detail is rare, and I appreciate having access to it all.
One thing I love about Simply Earth is their commitment to giving back. They donate 13% of their profits to combat human trafficking, which is an incredible initiative.
Pros of Simply Earth:
- Affordable monthly subscription box ($39).
- Transparent about oil testing, sourcing, and constituents.
- Comprehensive safety and usage information on each product page.
- Strong focus on community and education.
- Gives back 13% of profits to fight human trafficking.
Cons of Simply Earth:
- Limited variety compared to larger brands.
- No loyalty rewards program like Young Living’s Essential Rewards.
Young Living: Tried, True, and Premium Quality
I’ve been a Young Living member for over two years, and their quality and variety keep me coming back. Young Living’s Seed to Seal promise ensures that everything from planting the seed to sealing the bottle is done with the highest standards. They’ve been in the business for decades, and they’ve perfected the art and science of essential oil extraction.
Young Living is also a strong educational brand, with tons of resources available to their members. Being an MLM, Young Living offers a sense of community and support through various online groups, classes, and mentoring. While they do get criticism for their MLM structure, I’ve found the community aspect beneficial, especially for beginners.
Young Living oils come at a higher price point, but the quality is exceptional. Plus, they’re revamping their entire business model with new Subscribe and Save options and a complete website makeover, which will make shopping even easier!
Pros of Young Living:
- Seed to Seal promise guarantees top-tier quality.
- Extensive variety of essential oils and other wellness products.
- Strong community and educational resources.
- Trusted and established brand.
Cons of Young Living:
- Higher price point.
- Information on oil constituents and testing isn’t as readily available as Simply Earth’s.
- MLM model might not appeal to everyone.
Price Comparison
While both brands offer high-quality oils, Simply Earth is typically more affordable. Here are a few side-by-side comparisons of popular oils (all 15 mL bottles):
- Lavender: Young Living – $25.25 (wholesale), Simply Earth – $13.99.
- Lemon: Young Living – $12, Simply Earth – $9.99.
- Peppermint: Young Living – $23, Simply Earth – $12.99.
Simply Earth oils are often significantly cheaper, but price isn’t everything—quality, sourcing, and your specific needs also play a huge role in deciding which brand to go with.
Final Thoughts: Which Brand is Right for You?
Ultimately, both Simply Earth and Young Living are fantastic options, depending on what you’re looking for. If you’re new to essential oils or prefer a more budget-friendly, educational approach, Simply Earth is a great choice. The monthly subscription box is perfect for gradually making non-toxic swaps in your home, and their transparency is reassuring.
On the other hand, if you’re looking for premium quality, an extensive product range, and a strong community, Young Living might be the better fit. Yes, the prices are higher, but the brand has built a stellar reputation over the years.
Whichever brand you choose, both offer an excellent way to incorporate essential oils into your daily life, whether it’s for health, cleaning, or simply creating a calming atmosphere at home.
shop Simply Earth // $40 BACK WITH COUPON CODE: TOREYNOORAFREE
Simply Earth is an essential oil company with ethically sourced, GC/MS-tested oils. They offer a monthly subscription box with 4 essential oils, 6 recipes, and recipe ingredients for just $45 a month. My code TOREYNOORAFREE gives you a $45 gift card to use on future purchases. When you subscribe you also get access to an essential oil hero course to learn all the ins and outs, and a free big bonus box with carrier oils and bottles + Simply Earth gives back 13% of profits to help end human trafficking.
Essential Oil Brands We Approve Of
- EDEN’S GARDEN: the best-smelling blends/synergies
- MOUNTAIN ROSE HERBS: a rustic organic brand with lots of other good products like teas etc
- PLANT THERAPY: great prices and blends/kits for families
- REVIVE: amazing prices, dupes for the popular brands
- ROCKY MOUNTAIN OILS: DIY/usage videos on their socials
- SIMPLY EARTH: the one for DIY lovers & sub box lovers
SHOP MY DIGITAL PRODUCTS
AROMATHERAPY DIY MUST HAVES
DIFFUSERS I LOVE
*NOW AVAILABLE*
I just launched a series of guides on essential oils and specific concerns. Think your one stop shop for all things essential oils. These guides are packed with everything you need to know + recipes and tons of uses. There are also some freebies in my store too. Shop here
Disclaimer:
Essential oils can be potent and may interact with certain medications or cause allergic reactions. It’s essential to consult with an Aromatherapist before using essential oils, especially if you have any pre-existing health conditions or are pregnant or breastfeeding. I am now a Certified Aromatherapist! I you’d like to schedule a consultation with me email me at hello@toreynoora.com
Thanks for watching!
Your review of Simply Earth versus Young Living was excellent! I wonder – when looking at pricing, do you think the MLM aspect adds to the price? And do you feel it’s good value to shop from an MLM even when it’s a bit more expensive because it might be helping someone start their own business? I’ve shopped both MLM and regular retail – I’m currently in an MLM and am struggling with this question myself.
Thanks for watching! I think a lot of what goes into the pricing with YL is the quality. But I am also all about supporting MLM’s when it’s a friend because you are supporting their “business”! : ) I ALSO love YL because I get 25% back each month through their essential rewards program.