Young Living vs Simply Earth Essential Oils + Which One I Use

When it comes to essential oils, choosing the right brand is crucial to ensure you’re getting a high-quality oil that has the correct therapeutic benefits. Young Living and Simply Earth are two prominent players in the essential oils market, each with its own unique characteristics and offerings. In this blog post, we’ll delve into a detailed comparison of Young Living Essential Oils and Simply Earth Essential Oils, covering aspects such as their founding history, company profiles, pricing, quality measures, pros, and cons.

Founded

Young Living Essential Oils:

Young Living was founded in 1993 by Gary Young, who had a passion for essential oils and their potential benefits. The company started with a commitment to producing and distributing pure, authentic essential oils and providing a platform for individuals to achieve overall well-being through natural products.

Simply Earth Essential Oils:

Simply Earth is a newer player in the essential oils industry, founded in 2015. The brand was established with a mission to make high-quality essential oils accessible and affordable to everyone. Simply Earth offers a subscription box service that includes essential oils and other natural products, making it convenient for consumers to explore and use essential oils in their daily lives.

About

Young Living Essential Oils:

Young Living emphasizes the use of pure, therapeutic-grade essential oils extracted from plants grown on their own farms or sourced from trusted partners. They follow a Seed to Seal® quality commitment, which involves rigorous testing, sustainable farming practices, and maintaining transparency throughout the production process. Young Living is also a multi-level marketing company.

Simply Earth Essential Oils:

Simply Earth aims to offer 100% pure, natural essential oils that are free from additives and fillers. They source their oils from around the world and are committed to providing quality products at affordable prices. Simply Earth also donates 13% of their profits to fight human trafficking. Simply Earth’s blends and recipes are created by certified Aromatherapists.

Pricing

Young Living Essential Oils:

Young Living is on the higher end of the price spectrum in the essential oils market. The pricing of their oils can vary based on factors such as rarity, sourcing, and production processes. They offer various sizes and blends, giving customers options based on their preferences and budget.

Simply Earth Essential Oils:

Simply Earth positions itself as a more budget-friendly option in the essential oils market. Their subscription box service is designed to provide a cost-effective way for customers to access essential oils and experiment with different oils and blends. Additionally, they offer individual essential oils and other products at competitive prices.

Quality Measures

Young Living Essential Oils:

Young Living is known for its strict quality control measures. They employ rigorous testing protocols, including Gas Chromatography and Mass Spectrometry (GC/MS) among other tests, to ensure the purity and potency of their essential oils. Their oils are tested in house primarily, third party tested if needed. Young Living also emphasizes sustainable and ethical sourcing practices.

Simply Earth Essential Oils:

Simply Earth is committed to providing high-quality essential oils and conducts testing to verify the purity and authenticity of their products. While they may not have the same level of extensive testing as some larger brands, they strive to ensure their oils are free from adulteration and meet industry standards. Their oils are third party tested.

Pros

Young Living Essential Oils:

• Strong focus on quality and purity.
• Extensive product range, including unique blends.
• Established reputation and a large customer base.

Simply Earth Essential Oils:

• Affordable pricing, especially through their subscription box service.
• Commitment to transparency and charitable contributions.
• Accessible to a wide range of consumers due to competitive pricing.

Cons

Young Living Essential Oils:

• Higher price point compared to some competitors.
• Some critics argue that the multi-level marketing structure may lead to inflated prices.

Simply Earth Essential Oils:

• Limited variety compared to more established brands.
• May not have the same extensive testing and quality control processes as larger, more established brands.

Which One Do I Use?

We slowly (over the course of 2-3 years) transitioned away from Young Living, I don’t currently use or purchase any Young Living oils anymore, the prices are just far too high and the rewards program/subscription type of website is not my fave.

Essential oil brands we use and love

• SIMPLY EARTH: the one for DIY lovers & sub box lovers. Code TOREYNOORAFREE gives you $45 after you subscribe.
• EDEN’S GARDEN: the best smelling blends/syneriges
• HOHM: great blends, aesthetic bottles, well made diffusers
• JADE BLOOM: lots of essential oil education
• MOUNTAIN ROSE HERBS: rustic organic brand with lots of other good products like teas etc
• PLANT THERAPY:  great prices and blends/kits for families
• REVIVE: amazing prices, dupes for the popular brands
• ROCKY MOUNTAIN OILS:  DIY/usage videos on their socials

*NOW AVAILABLE*

I just launched a series of guides on essential oils and specific concerns. Think your one stop shop for all things essential oils. These guides are packed with every single thing you need to know + recipes and tons of uses. There are also some freebies in my store too.  Shop here

Young Living and Simply Earth both have their unique strengths and offerings in the essential oils market. The choice ultimately depends on individual preferences, budget, and priorities, whether it’s a focus on well-established brands and a wide range of products (Young Living) or affordability and accessibility (Simply Earth). It’s essential to do thorough research and consider your specific needs before making a decision on which brand to choose for your essential oil needs.